The first 2 seasons absolutely deserve 5 stars. The 3rd season however only deserves 2.5 maybe 3. I fell like audiences were drawn in to the darkness of this version of Sabrina and collectively i think everyone enjoyed just how dark the show was and how it pushed the envelope and really gave us an original horror series. Season 3 however really just went in a total different direction tone wise. It was much lighter, not only in concepts but it color as well. Lots of pastels and it really played it safe. The pagans could have been made so much darker and really gone into the sacrificial moments with more fear and gave the audience a high stakes environment, but they didnt. Majority of season 3 felt cheesy and the musical numbers seemed like something that belonged in Glee not a horror story. So it really put a lot of people off. Season 3 had potential but the execution was just extremely flat. You have a giant success on hand when the church and all the Karens of the world are boycotting and throwing a fuss at the thematic elements of the series (like they did with Harry Potter) and now it feels like Netflix caved and made it for children and pre-teens. The musical episodes HAVE TO GO. Part 4 will be a giant test.