Voice Acting: 10/10
Visuals: 10/10
Plot: 9/10
Gameplay/Fighting: 7.2/10
I have played about 5 hours so far and have really enjoyed every second of it. The story line is great, the voice acting is very well done, and the visuals are stunning. The only place the game lacks a bit is in the gameplay. The fight/game play loop gets slightly boring after 5 hours but it still allows for a good time.
I know there are complaints about a more straightforward and not so rewarding world but I think that is one of the good things about the game. If you do not enjoy some hand holding, you will not enjoy this game. If you want a chill game with good gameplay, amazing music, and a cute plot then South of Midnight is for you.
All in all, I would recommend it if you are looking for those Xbox 360, Summer vacation, new game, snacks out type of vibe.