(played on Nvidia 2080 ti, Story mode only) This is just an average game. Apart from wonderful graphics and good design, everything else is mediocre or poor.:
1. Controls are garbage. This game has one of the worst control schematics.
2. Wanted/ witness system sucks. Random people will report you for defending yourself.
3. Unnecessarily dragged. The game is actually very short but it is made in such way that it will give you sense that it is very long gameplay.
a) Most of things will involve you from going from one place to other travelling across vast map.
b) Challenges are not parallely completed, instead they are to be done in serial which will take significantly longer to complete. For example: challenge 5 of bandit quest requires you to get $250 bounty. If you previously had completed this challenge, before unlocking it, you will have to do it all over again.
c) The game loves making you wait for most of the things. And most of the things are content locked until later chapters.
4. Poor accessibility. The game menu is mess. Fast travel option requires a lot of preparation. Poor save/ load option. Hard to find items you are carrying. Everything requires waiting from opening satchel to calling horse. Managing guns is a hot mess.
5. Story is bland. Generic family/ revenge drama. Choices does not matter. Very low effort dialogue changes from honor level. Also feels like lots of content is scratched and game feels incomplete.
In short mediocre game and won't recommend to anyone who is not hardcore rockstar fan.