I don't understand the low ratings for the show. I see people complaining about dialog, acting, and writing... this is Star Wars. If we didn't have dialog to complain about it wouldn't be Star Wars. Not everything can be Stellan Skarsgård's Andor monologue.
There are some weird plot things, which I won't spoil. But the general story is interesting. The casting seems decent. It has pew pew and laser swords.
Tldr: It's not Ibsen. But it's decent Star Wars.