Dave Caslaw

The critical acclaim for this superb film is justly deserved, given it’s true and harrowing story. Just some minor criticism though. Basic errors which I’m surprised got past Clint Eastwood and his military adviser, indeed, the same ‘artistic license’ often seen in other military dramas. Under no circumstances do military personnel take personal mobile phones into combat, make or receive such calls in contact situations! Ridiculous! Also, a loaded weapon is never propped up vertically against a flat wall. If it fell, it could be discharged accidentally, disclosing a concealed location or causing a friendly fatality. Also beards and unshaven male soldiers - not sure this is allowed in US Forces! Notwithstanding, a very sobering watch and highly recommended.

An ambitious tale, with outstanding action sequences, though the audacious plot does stretch the imagination somewhat! A query. Why is the Metropolitan Police Commissioner referred to as ‘Chief Inspector’? Does nobody check such basics in the screenplay?

A very poignant portrayal of the horrors of World War 1, its aftermath and the conflicting attitudes of the time. Very well cast and acted throughout. Appropriate use of original footage, well researched. Clever continuity with the key characters as their older selves. However, a minor criticism is that a military advisor should have explained the standard protocol for saluting in the British Army and the correct wearing of an Officer’s Sam Browne!