Melissa Peterman and Tahj Mowry are outstanding in this!! Their comedy plays off each other like a championship Wimbledon tennis match. They are brilliant every season, 1-6, and but for them, I would have stopped watching. Their love-hate relationship and matching personalities continually finds them teaming up in some kind of scuttle-butt-scheme which is always entertaining.
I gave the show 3 stars instead of 5 because:
1. The camera shots in seasons 1-2 continually cut short the finest baby antics - a laugh, a smile, a giggle, a funny face, a movement. Right at the moment you start to laugh, poof it's gone. They cut the scene off in a split second and don't hold the focus. You just begin to laugh and the shot is gone, and you're like, "What?" That was a frustrating let down.
2. Around season 4, the episodes all start to seem the same. Each episode always consisted of these elements: a dating conundrum, some kind of breakup-makeup-breakup-makeup fiasco, the desperately sought after one-night-stand, and someone apologizing - all mixed with some kind of big calamitous comedic high-jinks. I loved seasons 1-3, then midway through season 4, I found myself saying, "Come on, just get to the finale already."
3. The biggest disappointment with seasons 4-6 was that they faded Emma into the background and out of the main story. We see her basically in the background, looking like a "toddler robot," with a few staged "quips" here and there. By mid season 5, the twins who play Emma look absolutely miserable on set. They were always looking down, were expressionless except for having constant distressed and confused eyebrows, and looked like they just wanted to do their scene, say their one line, and get out of there. It seemed like those little precious ones were unhappy being there, and I really disliked that.
4. So much comedic potential of a single dad, let alone three guys together raising a little girl, was lost to the screen writers. The comedic material available that stems from the stages of baby hood through the toddler years could have kept us constantly laughing, but was non existent, because the show wasn't ever really about a single dad raising a baby girl. That was a huge disappointment.
Anyway, I liked the idea of the show, and it did well early on. I just wish it would have held true to it's inception idea and not ended up just being about sex and guy gets girl, girl gets guy stuff.