Her performance in Philly on 12/13 was lethargic and lazy. She barely sang and didn’t perform much. The backup singers, dancers and band did all the work. She trotted around the stage in different outfits singing falsetto that was often times barely audible. I was highly disappointed. I’ve been a Mariah fan since age 12 with the Vision of Love album (30+ years). I felt very ripped off by the way she « performed » and will never pay to see her again. I’ve not even listened to her music since the concert because I was so disappointed. Mariah, you did not become famous and sell millions singing like you did on 12/13/2023. If your singing voice is truly gone, it’s only fair to the fans to hang it up already.