Noble theme, noble intentions alone don't make a good cinema. After OCTOBER, Shoojit Sircar delivers another film that is a pain to watch even when you are trying desperately to like it. The extended sequences of pain and misery exasperate u when you clearly feel the message could have been delivered in 75% less time. Inconsistent and largely Incoherent, the film tries unsuccessfully to build a mystery in the background and ends up leaving you frustrated thinking at what could have been.