*SPOILERS*
Pros:
The moments where they don't stare at each other for 5 minutes at a time or the camera doesn't pan from one face to another are extremely well acted. Unfortunately this feels like a very limited portion of this movie.
Before Brad Pitts' character dies in the accident, the movie was very good.
Cons:
The director was obsessed with closeups of faces about every 10 minutes it felt like. It added very little to the movie and got very tedious to watch over and over again.
3 hours?!?!? This movie can be cut to 2-2.5 hours without lowing any of the riveting monotone commentary complaining about how hard love is to find and how it isn't fair that you have to die.
Brad Pitt is too serious an actor to be playing a child-like character that is supposed to reference 'Death'. Also, while on this subject, is there a reason he's never tried to be human a long time before now? Did he see a hot girl and think "this is my time to kill someone and possess their body"? Was that just a coincidence? Never established, I supposed it is up to the imagination.
Hot Parrish daughter watches her dad go over the hill and not come back. I am assuming she figured out that Brad Pitt is actually Death but she shows no emotion. Check her into a psych ward!
Conclusion:
This movie would be immediately more watchable on a replay if I skipped all of the staring and jumped straight over the start so the movie can be consistently nonsensical in its entirety.
3/10