Mel M

The book has been one of my favourites but this movie has disappointed me. 1. She should be dressed more femininely, shy, and much younger! 2. Atlas in my imagination was a skinny blond guy with light blue eyes, he had a big house with a guest room!!! What happened? A few details were missing like that fridge magnet!!! The journal!! Oh, and the gay friend she brought with her to the party!!! And I think it was his place to say what happened to his brother and what the anger trigger was way before the divorce. Oh and when Atlas took her to the hospital?? In the book she was bleeding everywhere but on the movie was cuz of a bite? And she phoned him cuz she memorised his phone number!!! Anyway I don’t think she was the right choice for this role nor was Atlas. Can’t wait for the next one, it starts with us!!! Btw what was she wearing? Why was she dressed like Adam Sandler!!!

Not the right casting choice! Just ruined my childhood memories

Wrong main character! She’s not funny and makes the whole movie cringe. The story is good but I wish they didn’t go with Amy.