I have seen my fair share of Live Action Adaptations. Most fall flat while others are just cringe. Only a handful were entertaining and stayed true to the elements of the manga that birthed them.
Hence this is why there is something called the Live Action Curse.
BUT One Piece blew the curse out of the water!
I have been an OP fan since I began with the Anime (yes episode 1) and then stopping at Water 7 arc (that was years ago) to binge on the manga.
So as a fan of this decade long world. I must say BRAVO!
The world building, narrative, pacing, storytelling and the wonder and exuberance OP is know for has been embodied in just 8 episodes. No second was boring. The action and fighting sequences (which I was apprehensive about) made me think of Pirates of the Caribbean and the casting was stellar!
I admit having reservations about Inaki Godoy as Luffy BUT his energy and boyish charms only get better as you watch. Makenyu IS Zoro, enigmatic and a talented swordsman who is really cool from the get go, Emily Rudd portrays Nami well and I felt her pain during the Arlong Park Arc, Jacob as Usopp (while missing his long trade mark nose) nails the part as well and I grew to love him and lastly Taz as Sanji was perfection without going too overboard on the charm as he cooks his way into my heart.
Other castings I adore were Coby ( this boy is just so cute!) and Helmeppo (and their enemies to friends character development). Vice Admiral Garp (who is serious one second and laughing maniacally the next) and Mihawk (seriously I got goosebumps seeing him and his fighting scene onscreen for the first time)!
They did take out a lot of details and rearranged a few things to keep this entire saga to 8 episodes but I would say that it did not feel empty despite the changes. Only die hard fans know which minor characters and sequences were cut off. But the results are satisfactory. Why mess with success? There is always the next season (please be longer than 8 episodes)
To end this positive review. The childhood memories of each Straw Hat Pirate were sprinkled through other series very well and it ties up rather well at the end of episode 8.
Final Verdict: This is the golden standard for making a live action series. Absolute fun to watch for older kids (just cover their eyes from a few ahem scenes and blood and self harm stuff) and adults alike!
NETFLIX DON'T YOU DARE CANCEL THIS SERIES! I NEED S2, 3,4,5,6 NOW!
ODA SENSEI! I WILL NEVER DOUBT YOUR STAMP OF APPROVAL ANYMORE!
Fun fact: try watching it in Japanese dub. It actually worked really well for me.