A faithful recreation of the 16 year old game, however, the obvious and widespread acceptance of stagnation that keeps this game from deviating from its original state, even if only balance changes, keeps me from rating it five.
The nostalgia was great, but 15 years is long enough to know how to take the edge off of unbalanced pvp. All that would have been needed is diminishing returns on CC, like in TBC.
PvE requires no changes.