Rosemary Mckibbin

Loved, loved, loved this film from beginning to end, acting was superb, thoroughly believable, casting superb , music fantastic. Have never been a fan of Lady Gaga until now, what a talent, Bradley Cooper also great both acting and directing, Sam Elliott played his part wonderfully well too. Am hoping that the Oscar's will reward this brilliant film.

Awful film, worst I have ever had the misfortune to sleep through! Don't waste your time or money on this. Can't believe how many awards this has won and been nominated for. All great actors but truthfully woeful, is there even a story to this??