i think the books are good(although haven't read them at all). they have to be because people are loving this show but i don't think its as great as they are praising it(again haven't read the books just about the show)and as far as game is concerned it doesn't really matter how the gane was cause you don't make a show based on a game and certainly don't want it to be like the game you played cause these are two different things and the show doesn't make sense even as a fantasy it's not convincing. i don't want to compare it with GOT but can't help it they took everything GOT had and put it in there first season alone now again i am saying i haven't read the books and i am sure these ideas are real but the story has to make sense somewhere the witcher is played by the superman who does an increadible job infact everyone on the show looks great they act great the graphics are stunnig the music the set everything is beautifull. bit the problem is the story. just because you have a lot of money doesn't mean that you have to make stupid things they try so hard to make it look like a meaningful show where things happen for a purpose and there is good and evil and things like that. but it fails at it horriblly ican't see what i am typing now but i hope you don't judge me onbased on my reviwe its just that when read the reviwes i just thoight people are stupid for even watching the show