This movie was really well done. I went into it with some doubts due to all of the bad reviews- but I should have known better. Yes it is a bit of a musical, but not nearly the way some people are making it out to be. There is just enough singing to make it work- and the singing is done in a very artistic way. I found it refreshing. I look forward to seeing it again, as it felt very layered and well thought out. Gaga is as gorgeous and charming as ever and her chemistry with Phoenix is very evident. Loved it all.