From the perspective of a huge Halle Berry fan..this movie is highly rewatchable, just don’t take it so seriously…. it has some flaws and some plot holes in it…. but i’m not reviewing Citizen Kane here. This is a very brief synopsis, with *spoiler.
Halle Berry plays a respected psychiatrist for the criminally insane that works in a prison / psych ward. She becomes possessed by a murdered girl/ aborition, looking to seek justice thru her….or at least bring her murderers to light…..that is to say, through HB’s character, Miranda. Some great photography, a couple of scares, and an amazing cast - Penelope Cruz, a very young looking Robert Downy Jr, ( who broke Halle Berry’s arm while filming — apparently with very little remorse..?) Charles Dutton, Bernard Hill…, who are all excellent. The chemistry between HB and RDJ is something i would have liked to see further explored, here, and possibly in other movies. I really like the brooding, dark, bluish color pallet of the movie, it’s always raining and there’s lighting, and when the aborition makes an appearance, the electricity goes haywire.
Bottom line- the good guys aren’t what they seem to be and Miranda, from her jail cell, escapes to solve the mystery and expose everyone for the deviates that they are, inspite of no one believing her wild story of “seeing” the “dead girl”.
It’s a fun ride, as a big HB fan, who feels she really got short changed by being offered weak movies and roles ..and is often harshly reviewed, but ALWAYS gives 100 percent! The director finds a way… through numerous scenes… to get her entire body in this movie, even if in brief snippets, just enough to keep you watching. As HB is already an Oscar winner here, and is coming off being a Bond girl, i’m conflicted... as i wish she got offered more top flight roles in better movies but at the same time, i love seeing her exploited for her unparalleled beauty which is on full display here. I guess it did pay off cause her next movie was the underrated Catwoman ( good payday for HB, and if they would just edit 3 scenes down a bit, and DELETE 3 scenes, the movie is much better ) Back to Gothika, It’s about 90 mins and it goes by in a blink.
Watch the movie, then watch it with the director commentary the next night, if u have the dvd. Also on the dvd is an interesting music video of Limp Bizqit doing a cover of The Who’s “Behind Blue Eyes” i’m still hurting from watching Fred Durst making out with HB… while he somehow switches from inmate to Dr.,then leaving the HB character to rot in the cell.
So if u want to break out the popcorn and catch a fun flick, watch it. If u want to see Citizen Kane or Casablanca…. then watch those movies another time.