Prabjit Samra

I believe that the movie's true depth may not have been fully grasped by everyone. While I acknowledge that the trailer and cover might be somewhat misleading, it appears that the profound message of the film is being overlooked. The story portrays five individuals who have led challenging lives, involving theft, misconduct, and excessive drinking. However, their decision to assume the roles of Sikhs in the narrative brings about a transformative change, largely catalyzed by the practice of "ardas" and its inherent potency—a fundamental aspect of Sikh culture. This spiritual transformation is reminiscent of the influence of Guru Nanak's words, which have significantly shaped the Sikh community. In essence, I interpret the film's underlying message as illustrating how Sikhism can empower those who have lost their way through the strength of prayer. I desired a greater focus on showcasing Sikh characters and their journey within the film, rather than overly emphasizing Zahoor's love story. Additionally, I hoped for a deeper exploration of Sikh teachings and its rich historical context throughout the movie.

Sam Levison's portrayal of women leaves much to be desired. It's evident that he lacks a genuine understanding of the complexities of being a woman. While "The Idol" held promise as a show, it was marred by excessive sexualization. Did every moment really require an explicit scene? Amy Seimetz's approach, which would have delved into the experiences of child stars, had me eagerly anticipating a fresh perspective, given my fond memories of watching Miley Cyrus and Selena Gomez grow up in the spotlight. However, this vision was derailed by Sam Levison's involvement. Lilly Depp Rose's performance was undeniably impressive, but the overt sexualization of her character was disconcerting. While acknowledging the beauty of the human body, the show's focus on this aspect seemed excessive. The potential for a deeper exploration of the sinister realities of LA and fame, particularly in relation to Tetros cult, was overshadowed by a missed opportunity. I genuinely enjoyed Chaim's portrayal by the actor; his character was a standout element of the show. It led me to ponder that within the industry, individuals akin to Chaim and Destiny might be encountered, adding a sense of authenticity to the narrative. I must concede that certain scenes featuring Lilly Depp Rose did evoke emotional responses, largely due to her skilled acting. In summary, the overall verdict on the show is middling at best.